Journey

Three-Way Collaboration on Contract Operation that Drives Business GrowthNEW

A defining feature of Canon's Intellectual Property Contract Team is the early involvement of the contract team in each project. By working closely with the development team and business team from the outset, the contract team helps drive business forward while also keeping future business expansion in view.
For this article, we brought together members of the contract team from IP Division and the development team and business team for semiconductor devices to discuss how they collaborate on projects involving sales of image sensors and other Canon semiconductor device products to external customers.
In the following discussion, they will explain how this three-way collaboration supports contract operations and helps advance the business.

From left: Tomohiro Yamaoka Manager, Yukie Kambe (Intellectual Property Contract Team)
Yukio Chiba Senior Principal Engineer (Semiconductor Device Development Team)
Maki Maeda Manager, Kei Oka Lead Specialist (Semiconductor Device Business Team)

- First, could each of you tell us about your role?

Yamaoka (Contract Team): When the development team and business team seek to launch a new business, the role of the contract team is to help them build partnerships with external companies under optimal contract terms, while also keeping future business expansion in mind. Because every project is different, we place great importance on working closely with the development team and business team to determine the best approach and contract terms for each case.

Chiba (Development Team): The role of the development team is to create competitive semiconductor device technologies and turn them into products. As we work to expand sales to external customers, we often need to hold technical discussions with external companies. We therefore pay close attention to ensuring that the necessary technical information is exchanged within an appropriate scope so that development can proceed smoothly.

Maeda (Business Team): The business team works directly with external companies, our customers, on projects involving sales of semiconductor device products. Our role is to move business forward while building trusted relationships with customers. By understanding customer needs and proposing Canon's technologies and products, we help create new business opportunities and expand projects. Through ongoing dialogue with customers, we consider the best possible proposals and move each project forward.

Collaboration among the development team, business team, and Contract Team from the earliest stages of a project

- How do you work together in your day-to-day work, given your different roles?

Kambe (Contract Team): For each project, we review and refine the contract terms to avoid imposing undue constraints on future business. At the same time, we need to avoid spending so much time on that review that affects business speed. Drawing on past cases and accumulated knowledge, we therefore strive to propose an approach suited to each project to the development team and business team as early as possible.

Chiba: When the contract team becomes involved at an early stage, such as when a potential customer has been identified, it becomes much easier for the development team to clarify how to proceed and what issues need to be examined. For example, when we engage in technical discussions with an external company that is a customer, we first clarify exactly what information we need to receive from that company. We then limit the scope as much as possible so that it does not affect Canon's independent development. By clarifying in advance what information may be received from the external company, the development team can conduct its technical review without unnecessary hesitation or confusion.

Oka (Business Team): When the contract team organizes how a project should proceed and the development team carefully examines the relevant technologies, it becomes much easier for the business team to explain to customers the extent to which Canon's technologies and products can be provided and under what conditions. In particular, being able to consult with the contract team at an early stage allows us to clarify the direction of the project and the proposed terms before approaching the customer, which in turn makes it easier for the business team to move the project forward.

Determining the direction of contract terms together

- When a customer presents specific contract terms and related requests, how do the contract team, development team, and business team work together to respond?

Chiba: For the development team, the most important thing is to communicate the project’s technical assumptions. For example, we organize and explain what technologies the customers has, which of Canon's technologies they want to use, and what specific technologies and products Canon will provide. Another important consideration is how the technical information and required specifications we need to receive from the customer could affect other projects and future business. By sharing these assumptions with the contract team, we can clarify the issues that require attention as the project moves forward and receive more precise advice from the contract team.

Maeda: For the business team, it is important to respond to customer requests while properly identifying the rights Canon must protect. Because decisions made in one project can also affect other projects and future business, we consider not only the individual project at hand but also the business as a whole. In doing so, we think about what kind of terms would be appropriate, taking into account the project's strategic position within the business and our long-term relationship with the customer. The development team brings the technical facts it has organized, and the contract team brings the contractual issues it has identified, and the three teams work together to determine the most appropriate terms and conditions.
Depending on the status of negotiations with the customer, members of the contract team have also joined meetings with the customer and discussed issues directly with the customer's attorneys. By having the contract team communicate Canon's position and intentions directly and with conviction, we were able to gain the customer's understanding and conclude agreements that satisfied both parties.

Kambe: Based on the technical assumptions shared by the development team, as well as the customer relationship and project importance shared by the business team, the contract team considers how to move the project forward while securing the rights Canon must protect and the elements that will become future assets. For example, rather than simply accepting the customer's requests as they are, we propose an approach more suited to the project by clarifying the scope of the technologies, products, and information Canon will provide, organizing the scope of the information to be received, and confirming in advance how rights will be handled.
In doing so, we first identify the conditions that are essential for Canon to continue using its technologies and rights on an ongoing basis. For negotiable issues, we then present the potential impact of each option, including the opportunities it may create and the constraints it may impose on future business, so that the business team and development team can compare the options and make informed decisions. We believe the important role of the contract team is to provide these decision-making materials and, together with the business team and development team, identify the most appropriate way forward for each project.
Our role is not simply to point out contractual concerns. We see it as our role to design and implement an approach that both Canon and the customer can accept.

The strength of three-way collaboration in bringing different areas of expertise together

- What are the benefits of discussing matters as a group of three?

Chiba: When a project is viewed only from the perspective of the development team, attention naturally tends to focus on whether it can be realized technically. By discussing the project together with the contract team and business team, however, we can organize not only its impact on other businesses but also the scope of information that should be received in light of that impact. In addition, by taking into account contractual issues and the direction of the proposal to the customer, we can conduct technical discussions with the customer more smoothly.

Oka: For the business team as well, these discussions make it easier to identify options for both meeting customer expectations and safeguarding what Canon needs to protect. The value of these three-way discussions lies in enabling us to consider not simply whether to accept or decline a request, but under what conditions both sides can move forward constructively. Because these discussions help us organize the issues, we are also able to explain Canon's thinking to customers in a more logical and structured way. In addition, these discussions deepen our understanding of contractual risks from a specialist perspective, which also helps reduce business risk.

Yamaoka: To move a project forward, it is essential to consider the technical, business, and contractual perspectives together. When the development team and business team share the assumptions and positioning of a project, the contract team can propose an approach that reflects the realities of the situation. In particular, when the development team explains the thinking and intentions of those on the ground, it gives added persuasive force when the contract team explains the contract terms to the customer.
We believe the role of the contract team is not simply to sort out terms and conditions, but to build a shared understanding that enables the project to move forward, based on technical considerations and business judgments. Through this kind of collaboration, we hope to support both progress on individual projects and future business expansion.

After the discussion

What emerged from this discussion was that the contract team does not simply apply projects into existing contract templates. Instead, it works closely with the business team and development team on a case-by-case basis to determine the best way to move the business forward.
The discussion also showed that, by bringing together technical, business, and contractual perspectives, the three teams can not only consider how best to respond to customer requests from multiple angles but also explain to customers consistently the thinking behind Canon's approach and the background to its contract terms.

By bringing together their respective areas of expertise and working toward the same goal, the three teams are able to achieve both speed and future business expansion. These ongoing efforts help address customers' challenges and create new business opportunities.